Since 1934
Receive A Free Quote call (973) 963-4268
Hawthorne (973) 423-1900
Totowa (973) 942-2026
Monday–Friday, 9 a.m.–5 p.m.

AFFILIATED COMPANIES

Our Affiliated Insurance Companies

Discover the wide range of trusted insurance companies who are affiliated with Mutual Agencies. For additional information on insurance products and services, premium billing, and other issues, please review the insurance company's website or contact them via phone.

Property & Casualty Insurance

AIG (877) 638-4244 American Collectors (800) 360-2277 Andover Companies (800) 225-0770 Baystate (800) 225-0770 Cambridge Mutual (800) 225-0770 Chubb Group (800) 884-3770 CNA (877) 276-7507
Cumberland (800) 232-6992 Encompass (866) 430-2916 Foremost (800) 527-3905 Hagerty (800) 922-4050 Hanover Insurance (800) 573-1187 Harleysville (800) 338-8301 Harleysville Flood (800) 338-8301 Hartford (866) 467-8730
J.C. Taylor (800) 345-8290 Liberty Mutual (800) 653-7893 Mercer Insurance (800) 223-0534 Mercury (800) 503-3724 Merrimack Mutual (800) 225-0770 MetLife (800) 422-4272 NJ Manufacturers (800) 232-6600
Peerless Insurance (800) 228-7830 Preserver Group (877) 883-6599 Progressive (800) 776-4737 Selective Flood (800) 777-9656 Tower Group (877) 883-6599 Travelers (800) 842-0108 Utica National (800) 274-1914 Zurich (800) 842-0205

Life & Health Insurance

Aetna (860) 273-0123 AIG/American General (800) 521-2773 Amerihealth (732) 726-6700 Banner Life (800) 638-8428 Cigna (800) 244-6224 Delta Dental(800) 452-9310 Fort Dearborn Life (800) 633-3696 Genworth Financial(888) 436-9678
Guardian Dental(866) 425-4542 HealthNet (800) 848-4747 Horizon Blue Cross (800) 355-2583 John Hancock (800) 732-5543 MetLife (800) 638-5000 Oxford Health Plans (888) 201-3080 Prudential (800) 944-8786 United Healthcare (888) 545-5205